The most important tip I can give you on Cayman Islands local food, and the only one that will make you elevate from being a tourist to becoming a real traveler immersed in the local culture, is “Stay away from McDonalds“.
When visiting Cayman Islands, there is awesome local food to try. Head to the local eateries too, and go where the locals go. For me, the food, wine and and even the water is part of the travel experience.
What to Eat in Cayman Islands

Photo by Calgary Reviews
What to Drink in Cayman Islands

Photo by dvanhorn
Other local foods, or drinks that you recommend? Please add and comment.